Evidence Based Nursing Education and
Practice
Sivasubramanian
N.*
Assistant Professor, Sumandeep
College of Nursing, Vadodara, Gujarat
INTRODUCTION:
The
patients who receive research-based nursing care make "sizeable
gains" in behavioral knowledge, and physiological and psychosocial
outcomes compared with those receiving routine nursing care1. We
expect nurses to care with their hearts and minds to provide comfort to the
patient and we also expect them to be critical thinkers, good communicators and
abreast of all the important research findings. The National center for Nursing
Research at the National Institute of Health and the American Nurses association
cabinet on nursing research have promoted and provided guidance by focusing
research on nursing practice and nursing education2, 3.
What is Evidence-based nursing practice?
The
practice of nursing in which the nurse makes clinical decisions on the basis of
the best available current research evidence, his or her own clinical
expertise, and the needs and preferences of the patient4.
It
is the application of valid, relevant, and research-based information in nurse
decision-making. Used effectively, evidence-based nursing methods can be used
to dramatically enhance patient care and improve outcomes5.
Importance of evidence based nursing
1. EBP supports and informs clinical, administrative, and
educational decision-making.
2.
Combining
research, organizational experience (including quality improvement data and
financial data), clinical expertise, expert opinion, and patient preferences
ensures clinical decisions based on all available evidence.
3.
EBP ensures
efficacy (the ability to reach a desired result), efficiency (the achievement
of a desired result with a minimum of expense, time, and effort), and
effectiveness (the ability to produce the desired result).
4.
EBP weighs risk,
benefit, and cost against a backdrop of patient preferences. This decision
making encourages health-care providers to question practice and determine
which interventions work and which do not.
5.
EBP ensures that
nurses use evidence to promote optimal outcomes or equivalent care at lower
cost or in less time and that health-care provider promote patient satisfaction
and higher health-related quality of life.
Sources of Evidenced-Based Nursing:
Trial And Error:-
Here
nurses frequently try a variety of approaches to solve the problems. After some
time they settle on one approach that is more often than not effective. This
approach reduced critical thinking and wasted time.
Personal Experiences:-
Making
decisions based on their personal experience and it frequently influenced by
Tradition, Authority and Trial and Error.
Intuition:-
It
is defined as “Quick perception of truth without conscious attention or
reasoning”. In rare occasions a “Gut feeling” may be reliable.
Barrowed Evidence:-
It
can be useful because it fills gaps that exist in nursing science. Provides a
basis on which to build new evidence, and can be a stronger type of evidence
than sources that are not based on theory and science. It is important for
nurses to consider its fit with the nursing phenomenon.
Tradition:-
It
has long been accepted basis for information. Nurses can be so entrenched in
practice traditions that they fail to ask questions that could lead to changes
based in evidence. Consistent use of tradition as a basis for practice limits
effective problem solving and fails to consider individual needs
Authority:-
There
are various sources of authority such as books, articles, web pages and
individuals and groups. These are perceived as being meaning full sources of
reliable information, Yet in reality, The information
provided may be based in personal experience or tradition rather than
scientific evidence.
Scientific Research:-
It
is considered the best source of evidence. There are many different research
methods that can be used to describe and explain to nursing care7.
Best Resources for Evidence Base Nursing
education and practice:-
1. Printed Resources such as Encyclopedia, Hard books,
Guides and care plan modules.
2.
Electronic
Resources such as Professional journals, Popular magazine News papers Industry
bulletins
3. Subject -Specific Databases:-
|
(a)
TRIP-database |
http:/www.tripdatabase.com. |
It
support of EBP and simplify the nurses to accesses the web |
|
(b)
EMBASE |
http:/info.embase.com |
It
Provides comprehensive online access
to recent literature |
|
(c)
CINAHL |
http:/www.apa.org/psyin/o |
It
covers the area of nursing and allied health |
|
(d)
PSYCINFO |
http://www.apa.org/
psyinfo |
It
is an International coverage of nursing, education and other areas |
|
(e)
MEDLINE via Pubmed |
http://www.ncbi.nim.nih.govt |
Providing
coverage of Medline and other medical sciences literature |
|
(f)
Evidence-Based Nursing/ EB online |
http://ebn.bmjjournals.com |
Help
practicing nurses keep up with the manner. Based literature in a manageable8. |
Models of Evidence-based Practice:-
The Johns Hopkins Nursing
Evidence-Based Practice Model (JHNEBP) depicts three essential cornerstones
that form the foundation for professional nursing. These cornerstones are
practice, education, and research.
Practice
is the basic component of all nursing
activity (Porter-O’Grady, 1984). Nursing practice is the means by which a
patient receives nursing care. It is an integral component of health-care
organizations.
Education reflects the acquisition of
the nursing knowledge and skills necessary to become a proficient clinician and
to maintain competency.
Research
provides new knowledge to the
profession and enables the development of practices based on scientific
evidence.
Barriers of
Evidence-base Nursing Education and
Practice
1. Nurse Barriers: -
Lack
of
·
Time, Motivation,
Confidence and Research Knowledge regarding evidence-based strategies
·
Awareness of
Current Research
·
Interest/Value
for Research
·
Rewards for
implementing the findings into clinical practice.
·
Relevance of
research for practice.
·
Expectations and
reward systems for nurses to participate in research.
·
Understanding or
agreement with the conclusions of research reports.
2. Research
Barriers:
Lack of:
·
Relevance to
Practice
·
Rigorous
Methodology
·
Believable
Findings
·
Lack of
collaboration between researchers and clinicians.
·
Appropriate
Recommendations.
3. Organizational
Barrriers:
Lack of:
·
Access to
Journals/Research Resources
·
Funding to
Support New Technology
·
Expectations for
Research Participation
·
Rewards/Positive Reinforcement Staff
·
Time Allocated
for Research Participation
·
Staff Empowerment
to Make Changes
·
Support from
Administrators
·
Limited research
presentations and publications targeted for clinicians
4.
Communication Barriers:
Lack of:
·
Collaboration
Between Researchers and Clinicians
·
Presentations to
Audiences in Practice
·
Publications in
Clinical Journals
·
Understandable
Research Publications
·
Availability of
Consultants to Help Critique
Evidence Grading:
A1 =
Evidence from well-designed meta-analysis or well done systematic review with
results that consistently support a specific action (e.g., assessment, intervention,
or treatment)
A2 =
Evidence from one or more randomized controlled trials with consistent results.
B1 =
Evidence from a high quality evidence-based practice guideline.
B2 =
Evidence from one or more quasi-experimental studies with consistent results.
C1 =
Evidence from observational studies with consistent results (e.g., correlational descriptive studies)
C2 =
Inconsistent evident from observational studies or controlled trials.
D =
Evidence from expert opinion, multiple case reports, or national consensus
reports.
Recommendations
for Evidence-based nursing education in future:
·
Conduct
collaborative research development under international leadership
·
Develop
Continuing education on the use of the evidence base in decision making
·
Review clinical
guidelines and protocols in light of the latest research evidence
·
Create reward
system for successful in using an evidence base decision making
·
Documentation of
evidence from the opinion of expert informants and dissemination of reports of
expert committees
·
Review the
nursing curriculum at all levels
·
Include evidence
base for decision making in standards of clinical development process9.
CONCLUSION:
Evidence-based
practice (EBP) positions nurses to be a significant influence on health-care
decisions and a partner in improving quality of care. Beyond an expectation for
professional practice, EBP provides a major opportunity for nurses to enlighten
practice and add value to the patient experience. The nurse educators and nurse
administrator must be involved in the policy making process for our profession
in collaboration with health profession for empowerment through Evidence Based
Nursing Practice. The curriculum also should be developed for interpretation
for exploration.
REFERENCES:
1.
Heater BS, Becker AM, Olson R. Nursing interventions and patient
outcomes. A meta-analysis of studies. Nursing Research 1988; 37:303-7.
2.
Kathy Mallach, Tim Porter-o’ Grady,
Introduction to Evidenced based practice in Nursing and healthcare 59-60
3.
Nightingale F. Notes on nursing what it is and is not. London:
Churchill Livingstone, 1946. (First published in 1859)
4.
Mosby's Medical Dictionary, 8th edition. © 2009, Elsevier.
5.
Nicky Cullum is Director of the Centre for
Evidence Based Nursing at the University of York, UK and formerly UK Editor of
Evidence Based Nursing.
6.
Thompson C, Mc. Caughan D, Cullum N, Sheldon TA, Mulhall
A, Thompson DR. Research information in nurses’ clinical decision-making: what
is useful? J Adv Nurs2001; 36:376–88
7.
Nola A Schmidt, Evidence based-practice for nurses 6-8,96-98
8.
LoBiondo-wood, G(2002)Evaluating the validity of internet resources
1,3,4,11
9.
Swan.A.B Al-Gasser.N and Lang .M.N
2003 Global partnership to strengthen the evidence for nursing economics(
21,247-52)
Received on 21.01.2011 Modified
on 28.01.2011
Accepted
on 02.02.2011 © A&V Publication all
right reserved
Asian J. Nur. Edu. & Research 1(1): Jan.-March 2011; Page 19-22