Effect
of Bradley Method on Labour Outcome among Pregnant
Women at Selected Hospital, Coimbatore.
J. Roseline
Sharmila
Lecturer, College
of Nursing, SRIPMS, Coimbatore Tamil Nadu
E-mail:
Abstract
An
interventional study was conducted to promote the labour
outcome by adopting Bradley method. Quasi experimental one group post test
design was used to conduct the study. Seven antenatal women and their husbands
were selected conveniently as samples. Bradley method was imparted to couples under five sessions during last weeks of antenatal period.
Modified Alice Chacko Coping Response Scale (Esther
John, 2009) and modified Esther John Opinionnaire
were administered to obtain the data. Descriptive statistical analysis was
used. Most of the antenatal women were
shown high coping ability during labour (86%) and
high level of satisfaction on child birth experience (57%). Hence, it can be
concluded that Bradley method is found to be effective in promoting labour outcome.
INTRODUCTION:
Pregnancy is such an exciting time and the
changes that accompany pregnancy affect the women’s emotions. Hence the
pregnant woman needs the support very much from the caregiver (Bryanton, 1994). Last decade, a number of studies have
acknowledged and validated the importance of the presence of supporting persons
with women during labour (Madi,
Sandall and Bennet, 2004).
Childbirth preparation became popular
because it identified the need of most expectant mothers and their support
people as they began to reclaim their right to take an active part in their
experience and demanded a change in their care from their health care providers
(Moondragon, 2007). A good child birth preparation
helps couple to develop stress management techniques to deal with fear and pain
as well as good grounding in the risks and benefits of various obstetric
choices. This preparation helps them to empower women and their partners so
they may be able to stand up for the clinics they want and be able to decline
the choices they don’t want from the medical community (Rowlands,
1998).
Gagon, et al (1990) explained that childbirth
preparation tends to allow women to cope, to remain in control and thus able to
describe pain more manageable, even though it may be as intense as experienced
by an unprepared woman.
Husband and antenatal women both can be
comfortable with the idea of husband coached labour.
Husband can be the most significant source of emotional support and comfort.
Loving partners are one of the strongest tranquilizers and the most effective
pain relievers. Their nurturing presence may also encourage the flow of oxytocin, a hormone which helps labour
to progress more quickly (Green, 2003). For many fathers, the involvement in
birth gives them a chance to nurture and care of their new baby. Women who
nurtured by their male partners during pregnancy had few childbirth
complications and they will adjust easily in the postpartum period.
Robert Bradley developed this method in the
late 1940’s. This method emphasizes an extremely natural approach with few or
no drugs and little medical help during labour.
Fundamental philosophy of Bradley birth is that, with adequate preparation and
support from a loving, supportive coach, most women can naturally deliver their
babies. In the Bradley course of study, mates are trained to coach mothers
through childbirth using hands-on-techniques like massage and praise. Husband
coached labour is the main concept where husband is
allowed to remain inside the labour room to
participate actively in the labour process.
The Cochrane group conducted several
reviews of published trials regarding pregnancy and childbirth. In one review
of 15 trials involving over 12,000 women, the continuous presence of husband
coach reduced the likelihood of analgesia for pain relief, reduced operative
delivery and reduced dissatisfaction of women with their birth experiences (Hodnett, Gates, Hofmeyr and Sakala, 2006).
Combined five randomized trials involving
1,252 primiparous women at term with singleton
uncomplicated pregnancies. Researcher found that when continuous labour support was provided for women, the caesarean birth
rate decreased by 50%, length of labour was decreased
by 40% and the request for pain medication dropped by 60%. This research
concluded that continuous support in primiparous
women enhances maternal and fetal well being reduces medical interventions and
saves money for individuals and hospitals (Klein, et al., 1998).
The continuous presence of a supportive
companion during labour and delivery in Guatemala
shortened labour and reduced the need for caesarean
section and the other interventions. 412 healthy nulli
parous women in labour were
randomly assigned to a supported group (n=212) that was monitored by an
inconspicuous observer. Continuous labour support
significantly reduced the duration of labour, oxytocin use, forceps deliveries, rate of caesarean section
deliveries, maternal fever and prolonged infant hospitalization (Kennell and Klaus, 2003).
Since, a father can participate in labour and birth in different ways; nurses need to
encourage him to adapt the role most comfortable for him and for the woman,
rather than an artificial role. Supporting both the father and the mother in labour elevates the nurse’s role. It is another step
forward from merely providing custodial care to enacting a therapeutic role.
Nurse plays many professional roles in day to day activities. Among all, the
role as a comforter is very important in speaking soothing words to antenatal
women. They are the professionals available with the women all the time.
Nurse’s master mind utilized for childbirth preparation helps to alleviate
fear, anxiety and tension and promote quality in birthing.
OBJECTIVES:
·
To
implement Bradley method of child birth to women and their husband.
·
To
assess the outcome of labour among women undergone
Bradley method of Childbirth.
hypotheses:
(i)
Bradley method will facilitate high coping ability
among parturient.
(ii)
Bradley method will facilitate high satisfaction
level on child birth experiences among parturient.
METHODOLOGY:
The conceptual framework in this study was
based on Roy’s adaptation model. The
study was conducted for 30 days. Quasi
experimental one group post test design was adopted. The antenatal women who
were between 36-38 weeks of gestational age were considered as accessible
population. Convenient sample of 7 antenatal women and their husband were drawn
as sample for the study.
Description
of tools
Ø Demographic profile and obstetric history
Ø Partogram to assess the progress of labour
Ø Modified Alice Chacko
coping response scale (Esther John, 2009) to assess the coping response of the
parturient during labour. It was a structured
observational checklist, consists of 48 items.
Ø Modified Esther john’s structured Opinionnaire to assess the mother’s satisfaction level on
childbirth experiences. It was a structured questionnaire consists of 9 items.
Description
of intervention
Phase
I
The purpose of the present study was
explained to the couple. The demographic and obstetric history was collected by
personal interview. The couples were taught about Bradley method by using
booklet and demonstration on breathing techniques, relaxation and massage
techniques were done in five different sessions. The couples were encouraged to
re-demonstrate these techniques.
The
content of the teaching module was,
v Introduction to female reproductive system
v Introduction to Labour
v Concept of Bradley method and role of
husband in childbirth.
v Breathing exercices
v Massage
technique
v Relaxations
techniques
Phase II
During first stage, parturient was shifted
to labour room, where researcher allowed the husband
to be with his wife to provide emotional support and physical comfort by
performing massage. The progress of labour was
informed to the husband now and then by the researcher and obstetrician. The
partner was encouraged to give continuous support to his wife who was in labour. Progress of
labour was monitored through Partogram
and coping responses was assessed through questionnaire. After assessing the
outcome of labour in the first stage, the researcher
permitted the husband to remain in the labour room
till the crowning of the presenting part.
After the delivery, the mother’s satisfaction level on child birth
experiences was assessed by using an Opinionnaire.
DISCUSSION:
Demographic
variables of antenatal women
In this study, 7 antenatal women comprising
of age ranged from 20 – 30 years were studied. Among that, 57% of the antenatal
women belong to the age group of 29 – 32 years, 29% of them belongs
to the age group of 25 – 28 years and 14% of them were between the age group of
21 – 24 years. Out of 7 antenatal women,
57% of women were Under Graduates, 29% of them were Post Graduates and 14% of
them completed their higher secondary.
Demographic
variables of husband
Among 7 husbands, 57% of the husbands
belong to the age group of 30-34 years. 29% of them belong to the age group of
35-40 years and 14% of them were between age group of 25-29 years. Out of 7 husbands, 42% of them were Post
Graduates, 29% of them were Under Graduates and 29% of them completed their
higher secondary.
Distribution
of obstetrical data
Most of the antenatal women (57%) were multigravida and 43% of them were primigravida.
Present study revealed that, multigravida mothers
were shown high coping ability when compared to primigravida
mothers. Among 7 antenatal women, 71% of the antenatal women were between 35 –
36 weeks of gestational age, 29% of them belong to 37 – 38 weeks of gestational
age. Among 7 antenatal women, 57% of them had 8-10 hours duration of labour. 29% of them had 5-7 hours duration of labour. 14% of them had 11-13 hours duration of labour. Out of 7 antenatal women, all of
them undergone normal vaginal delivery. Among 7 husbands, 57% of them
were present during first stage up to 4-6 hours and 43% of them were present upto 7-10 hours. Present study revealed that more the
duration of presence of husband more coping ability was noted among parturient.
Distribution
of parturients based on score of Modified Alice Chacko coping response scale (Esther john, 2009)
The result reveals that, 86% of mothers who
have practiced Bradley method during labour were
shown high coping ability during first stage of labour.
14% of mothers were shown moderate coping ability during first stage of labour. Hence, the hypothesis, “Bradley method of
childbirth preparation increase the coping ability of the parturients”
is accepted.
Distribution
of satisfaction level of the mother based on Modified Esther john Opinionnaire
Most of the mothers were expressed (57%)
high satisfaction level on Bradley Method of childbirth. 43% of them were
expressed moderate level of satisfaction on Bradley method of childbirth which
was achieved through the presence of their husbands and psychological support
provided by them.
Major findings of the study:
1. Bradley method was effective in increasing
the coping ability of parturients during first stage
of labour.
2. 86% of the parturients
were shown high coping ability during first sage of labour.
3. 57% of the parturients
had high level of satisfaction and 43% of the parturients
had moderate level of satisfaction in childbirth experience.
4. Progression of labour
was accelerated with the help of Bradley method.
5. Husbands were actively participated in labour process.
6. All the mothers underwent normal vaginal
delivery with the use of Bradley method.
Recommendations:
1. Bradley method can be implemented from
third trimester onwards and results obtained to evaluate the quality of early
preparation.
2. A similar study can be conducted as a true
experimental study comprising of a control group.
3. A structured teaching programme
can be conducted to the staff nurses working in obstetric department about
Bradley method.
4. A comparative study can be conducted on
various childbirth preparation methods.
5. The study can be replicated with a larger
size for wider generalization of findings.
Nursing Implications:
The concept of Bradley method encourages
the role of husband in providing comfort measures in terms of relaxation
exercises and measure to cope up during first stage. It is one of the child
birth preparation methods aiming to improve the labour
outcome and its implications needs wide knowledge and practice. The practice of
Bradley method can be included in the nursing curriculum. Bradley method
facilitates the mother to cope with pain and increase the coping ability of
mother during first stage of labour. The midwife can
practice Bradley method to promote the labour
outcome.
Conclusion:
The study was conducted to find the effect
of Bradley method among pregnant women. Most of the women (86%) were shown high
coping ability during first stage of labour and 57%
of women showed high satisfaction level on child birth experiences. Hence, the
intervention was found to be effective in promoting labour
outcome.
REFERENCES:
1.
Adele Pilliteri. (2007). Maternal and Child Health Nursing. (5th
Ed.), Philadelphia: J.P. Lippincott Company, 523-526.
2.
Bradley,
R. (1981). Husband Coached Childbirth. (3rd Ed.), New York: Harper
Collins, 332.
3.
Bradley.
(1981). Bradley Method of Child Birth. Retrieved from
http://www.exortment.com/all/bradleymethod.html on Nov 28, 2009.
4.
Bryanton, J., Fraser-Davie, H. and Sullivan, P. (1994). Women’s Perception of Nursing Support
during Labour. Journal
of Obstetric, Gynaecologic and Neonatal Nursing, 23, 638-644.
5.
Gagnon,
et al., (1990). A Randomized Trial of One – To – One Nurse Support of Women in Labour. Birth, 24, 2,
71 – 77.
6.
Green.
(2003). Positive Effects of Presence of Partner. Retrieved from
http://www.birthpsychology.com/prep.html on Dec 10, 2009.
7.
Hodnett, E.
D., Gater, S., Hofmeyr, G.
J. and Sakala. (2006). Continuous Support for Women During Child Birth. Cochrane Library, 4, Oxford, UK: Update
Software.
8.
Hodnett,
E. and Osborn, R. (1998). A Randomized Trial Of The Effects
Of Support During labour. Journal of Obstetric and Gynecology and
Neonatal Nursing 16, 177 – 183.
9.
John,
E. (2009). A Comparative Study to Assess the Effectiveness of Selected Child
Birth Preparation Methods. An Unpublished Doctoral Thesis submitted to Annamalai University, Chidambaram.
10. Kennel. M. and Klaus. (2003). Continuous
Presence of Supportive Companion during labour,
Retrieved from http://pal.dec.org/PNACY760.pdf on July 11,2010.
11.
Klein, R. P., et al. (1998). A Study of Father in Child Birth. Birth Family Journal, 8, 161-164.
12.
Madi,
B. C., Sandall. J. and Bennet,
R. (2004). Effects of Continuous Support in Labour. Birth, 26, 1, 5-8.
13. Moondragon. (2007). Child Birth Preparation Classes.
Retrieved from http://www.moondragon.org/pregnancy/childbirthclasstype.html on
July 13, 2010.
14. Rowland. (1998). Birthing Classes.
Retrieved from http://www.kidshealth.org.pregnancy/birth-class.html on July 10, 2010.
15. Sosa, et al., (1998). Continuous Supports
during Labour. Retrieved from
http://pdf.dec.org/PNACY760.pdf on July 11, 2010.
Received on 27.07.2012 Modified on
12.08.2012
Accepted on 27.08.2012 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research 2(3): July-Sept.
2012; Page 109-112