Power point Versus Chalk and
Talk: Perception among Nursing Students an Exploratory Study
Ms. Divya
Shettigar1, Mrs. Priya Aranha2,
Mr. Sanil Vargehese3
1Lecturer,
Dept of Community Health Nursing, Yenepoya Nursing
College, Mangalore, Karnataka, India
2Lecturer,
Dept of Child Health Nursing, Yenepoya Nursing
College, Mangalore, Karnataka, India
3Lecturer,
Dept of Medical Surgical Nursing, Yenepoya Nursing
College, Mangalore, Karnataka, India
Corresponding Author Email:
ABSTRACT
Introduction: The emerging
technologies and the technological advances made day by day are changing the
methods and techniques of teaching around us. The technique of teaching has
seen drastic changes in the last decade with the new techniques available
ranging from Power-point presentation to the video class rooms which converts
the traditional class rooms to smart class rooms. Keeping this in mind the
present study was planned to compare the two instructional aids.
Method: In this study cross sectional descriptive survey was used. Nursing
students were selected through Non probability convenient sampling. The data
was collected using questionnaire based survey about their views and perception
of two methods of lecture delivery, viz: PPT
presentation and using a chalkboard. For each of the two methods, the students
were asked to rank nine comments on a four-point scale: strongly agree, agree,
disagree, or strongly
disagree . The data was analysed using SPSS version
16 and the results expressed as proportions.
Results:In our study where more than 97% of our study respondents
emphasized the value of chalk and talk and declared it as the more effective
and useful teaching tool in their learning experience compared to PowerPoint
(86%) and recommended it for teaching.
Conclusion: The study concluded that both chalk
and talk as well as power point presentation are the effective instructional
aids in nursing education and both can be used in combination for the effective
delivery of classroom instructions
KEY WORDS: Chalk
and Talk , PowerPoint , Perception , Nursing students.
INTRODUCTION:
Lectures have been
the most common form of teaching and learning since ancient times.1 Although discussion methods in small groups appear to be a
superior method of attaining higher-level intellectual learning.2
During the past 15-20 years the presentation
methods in the classrooms has changed from the traditional chalk and talk to
more advanced PowerPoint and smart classrooms methods. The most accepted
criterion for measuring good teaching technique is the amount of student
learning that occurs.
Students often have
little expertise in knowing if the technique selected by an individual
instructor was the best teaching technique or just “a technique” or simply the
technique with which the teacher was most comfortable.3
During a lecture,
both the visual and auditory senses are used to absorb information and here
assistance in the form of a visual aid is useful.4 A chalkboard is
uniquely effective as a medium of classroom instruction and has been used
commonly in lectures, while the use of transparencies with an overhead
projector (TOHP) is also popular.5
In traditional classrooms, a teacher’s basic
instructional tools for displaying information are chalkboards, multipurpose
boards, pegboards, bulletin boards and flip charts.6 To project
instructional materials, overhead transparencies displayed via an overhead
projector are still a commonly used classroom presentation methods.3
Recently the use of electronic presentations has become common and Microsoft
PowerPoint (PPT) is now the most popular instructional aid.7
The impact of technology has led to the increased
use of computers for presenting information in many of today’s classrooms.
Microsoft PowerPoint, hailed as an easy-to-use means of creating professional presentations
teachers for creating classroom presentations.8 A study found PowerPoint to be one of the most
widely used software programs in both an area educator preparation program and
local public schools.9 It is seen that
“more than 400 million copies of the program are currently in
circulation, and somewhere between 20 and 30 million PowerPoint-based
presentations are given around the globe each day”.10
Various studies have been conducted to assess the
effectiveness of lectures using PPT or other such media in comparison to
lectures using chalkboard, or the use of TOHP. According to one study,
traditional classes with blackboard presentation were the most favored by
students from biomedicine and medicine courses.11
Recently the use of
electronic presentations has become common and Microsoft PowerPoint (PPT) is
now the most popular package used out of all electronic presentations.12
Therefore, the
present study was planned in a selected nursing colleges
in the state of Karnataka, India, to assess the student’s perceptions of the
impact of PPT presentations in lectures compared with the traditional chalk and
talk method.
Objectives of
the study
To compare the perception of students regarding the
chalk and talk and PowerPoint
in Nursing Education.
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
A
questionnaire-based survey of the nursing students in a private nursing college
in Dakshina kannada , karnataka, India was conducted
after getting permission from the Principal and institutional ethics committee
of the college. Non-probability convenience sampling was
used. A total of 100
nursing students
completed the questionnaire. The students were asked to fill in
the following structured questionnaire about their views and perception of two
methods of lecture delivery, viz: PPT presentation
and using a chalkboard. For each of the two methods, the students were asked to
rank the following nine comments on a four-point scale: strongly agree, agree,
disagree, or strongly
disagree :
1. I
understand lecture better when the teacher uses this instructional aid
2. I feel the Teacher student interaction is more when
this instructional aid is used
3. Teacher-student eye contact is less when this
instructional aid
4. The lecture advances my understanding with this
instructional aid
5. This particular instructional aid
help me to concentrate and remember better
6. When this the Quality and
quantity of my lecture notes are not up to the mark.
7. The lecture delivery is interesting with this
instructional aid
8. The lecture content were informative
9. The lecture were audible with this instructional aid
10. The lecture content
were well organized when this instructional aid is used
11. Teacher remains
more professional
12. Teacher needs more
preparation for the class
The above twelve
parameters were analyzed on the basis of scale of grading, ie,
4 (strongly agree ), 3 (agree), 2 (disagree) and 1
(strongly disagree ).
The sum of all the students’ gradings
on each parameter was used to calculate the final weighted score. The overall
preference of the students is estimated using the method of weighted average,
for finding the weighted score of each parameter regarding the different
lecture delivery methods. The results were analyzed separately for nursing
students to see if there is any difference in their perceptions. The data was analysed using
SPSS version 16 and the results expressed as proportions.
RESULTS:
Main findings are
discussed under the following headings :
SECTION I: DESCRIPTION OF SAMPLE CHARACTERISTICS
Distribution
of nursing students according to the demographic characteristics
Majority 44% nursing students were in the age group of
26-30 years and 36% of age 31-35 years. 95% were female and 5% of were male, 77% were
Hindu and 12% Christian and 12% were
Muslim.35% were Postbasic BSc
nursing and MSc nursing students respectively, 30%
were BSc nursing students.54% were from second year,
30% from fourth year and 16% from first year.60% sometimes have exposed to classes with PPT and 40% had
always classes with PPT.
SECTION II: COMPARISON OF THE PERCEPTION OF STUDENTS
REGARDING THE CHALK AND TALK AND POWERPOINT IN NURSING EDUCATION (Table 1
and 2 )
Ø Students perceive that when chalk and talk method is
used 72(72%) agree and 25(25%) strongly agree that they understand lecture
better. Whereas 54(54%) students agree and 32(32%) strongly agree that
PowerPoint , when used they understand lecture better
Ø Students perceive that when chalk and talk method is
used 51(51%) agree and 35(35%) strongly agree that Teacher student interaction
is better. Whereas 43(43%) students agree and 28(28%) strongly agree that
PowerPoint, when used Teacher student interaction is better
Ø Students perceive that when chalk and talk method is
used 42(42%) agree and 13(13%) strongly agree that Teacher student eye contact
is less. Whereas 45(45%) students agree and 16(16%) strongly agree that
PowerPoint, when used Teacher student eye contact is less
Ø 69(69%) agree and 18(18%) strongly agree that lecture
advances their understanding when chalk and talk method is used. Whereas
66(66%) students agree and 18(18%) strongly agree that lecture advances their
understanding when PowerPoint is used
Ø Students perceive that when chalk and talk method is
used 52(52%) agree and 36(36%) strongly agree that they can concentrate and
remember better. Whereas 47(47%) students agree and 29(29%) strongly agree that
PowerPoint , when used they can concentrate and remember better
Ø 50(50%) agree and 10(10%) strongly agree that quality
and quantity of lecture notes are not up to mark when chalk and talk method is
used. Whereas 49(49%) students agree and 12(12%) strongly agree that quality
and quantity of lecture notes are not up to mark when PowerPoint is used
Ø Students perceive that when chalk and talk method is
used 52(52%) agree and 25(25%) strongly agree that lecture delivery is
interesting. Whereas 56(56%) students agree and 22(22%) strongly agree that
PowerPoint, when used lecture delivery is interesting.
Ø Students perceive that when chalk and talk method is
used 70(70%) agree and 17(17%) strongly agree that lecture content were
informative. Whereas 69(69%) students agree and 22(22%) strongly agree that
PowerPoint, when used lecture content were informative.
Ø Students perceive that when chalk and talk method is
used 66(66%) agree and 27(27%) strongly agree that lecture content were
audible. Whereas 65(65%) students agree and 24(24%) strongly agree that
PowerPoint, when used lecture content were audible.
Ø Students perceive that when chalk and talk method is
used 52(52%) agree and 35(35%) strongly agree that lecture content were well
organized. Whereas 48(48%) students agree and 29(29%) strongly agree that
PowerPoint, when used lecture content were well organized.
Ø Students perceive that when chalk and talk method is
used 52(52%) agree and 35(35%) strongly agree that lecture content were well
organized. Whereas 48(48%) students agree and 29(29%) strongly agree that
PowerPoint, when used lecture content were well organized.
Ø Students perceive that when chalk and talk method is
used 58(58%) agree and 26(26%) strongly agree that teacher remains more
professional. Whereas 51(51%) students agree and 28(28%) strongly agree that
PowerPoint, when used teacher remains more professional.
Ø Students perceive that when chalk and talk method is
used 47(47%) agree and 33(33%) strongly agree that teacher needs more
preparation for the class. Whereas 43(43%) students agree and 31(31%) strongly
agree that PowerPoint, when used teacher needs more preparation for the class.
Table 1 : Percentage wise distribution of perception of nursing
students regarding chalk and talk method.
|
Sr. no. |
Statements
regarding perception |
Strongly Agree |
Agree |
Disagree |
Strongly
disagree |
|
% |
% |
% |
% |
||
|
1. |
I understand lecture better when the teacher use this
instructional aid |
25 |
72 |
2 |
1 |
|
2. |
I feel the Teachers student interaction is better |
35 |
51 |
13 |
1 |
|
3. |
Teacher-student eye contact is less |
13 |
42 |
38 |
7 |
|
4. |
The lecture advances my understanding |
18 |
69 |
13 |
0 |
|
5. |
This instructional aid help
me to concentrate and remember better |
36 |
52 |
11 |
1 |
|
6. |
Quality and quantity of my lecture notes are not up
to the mark. |
10 |
50 |
34 |
6 |
|
7. |
The lecture delivery is interesting |
25 |
52 |
22 |
1 |
|
8. |
The lecture content were informative |
17 |
70 |
12 |
1 |
|
9. |
The lecture were audible |
27 |
66 |
7 |
0 |
|
10. |
The lecture content were well organized |
29 |
48 |
20 |
3 |
|
11. |
Teacher remains more professional |
26 |
58 |
15 |
1 |
|
12. |
Teacher needs more preparation for the class |
33 |
47 |
17 |
3 |
Table 2 : Percentage wise distribution of perception of nursing
students regarding Computerized digital presentation.
|
Sr. no. |
Statements
regarding perception |
Strongly Agree |
Agree |
Disagree |
Strongly
disagree |
|
% |
% |
% |
% |
||
|
1. |
I understand lecture better when the teacher use this
instructional aid |
32 |
54 |
12 |
2 |
|
2. |
I feel the Teachers student interaction is better |
28 |
43 |
26 |
3 |
|
3. |
Teacher-student eye contact is less |
16 |
45 |
34 |
5 |
|
4. |
The lecture advances my understanding |
18 |
66 |
16 |
0 |
|
5. |
This
instructional aid help me to concentrate and
remember better |
29 |
47 |
20 |
4 |
|
6. |
Quality and quantity of my lecture notes are not up
to the mark. |
12 |
49 |
36 |
3 |
|
7. |
The lecture delivery is interesting |
22 |
56 |
22 |
0 |
|
8. |
The lecture content were informative |
22 |
69 |
8 |
1 |
|
9. |
The lecture were audible |
24 |
65 |
11 |
0 |
|
10. |
The lecture content were well organized |
35 |
52 |
10 |
3 |
|
11. |
Teacher remains more professional |
28 |
51 |
20 |
1 |
|
12. |
Teacher needs more preparation for the class |
31 |
43 |
22 |
4 |
Fig 1 : AGREED INCLUDING STRONGLY AGREE RESPONSE
REGARDING THE MOST TEACHING LEARNING METHOD
86% of nursing students strongly agree that they prefer Powerpoint and 97% prefer chalk and talk method as the most
teaching learning method
DISCUSSION:
Teaching is an art. By making use of best instructional
aid, teacher can teach and make the students
understand, remember and reproduce well; thus improving the academic
performance of students.
Different technologies are becoming ubiquitous in
classrooms. The use of better teaching aid allows the students to understand
better. This also allows more time for interaction and further
understanding. Use of technology can be a very beneficial and time saving tool
for all teachers.
An evaluation by
the students can provide the teacher with useful feedback information regarding
the best teaching aid and teaching method.
In our study, students preferred combination of
teaching aids rather than individual teaching aid. Among the two
prevailing combination teaching methods, majority of the students have opted PPT + Black board as their preferred aid for the
better perception of subject.
This observation may probably be due to the fact that, inherent deficiency of
each method is compensated by the other. While blackboard teaching is deficient
in showing three dimensional diagrams, animated videos and sounds; the same can
be demonstrated using a Power Point presentation. Power Point presentations
take less time to present the same information as compared to Black Board teaching.
Blackboard teaching allows the students to take down the notes and diagrams
which is difficult with Power Point presentations as there is tendency to
deliver the lecture fast.13
The results of the study is
concordance with the study done by Chaudhary R
(2009). In their study also majority of the students (67.1%) favored the
combination of teaching aids. The drawback which the students pointed in Black
Board teaching, is that it takes time to draw a labelled
diagram on the board and during that time teacher’s eye contact with the
students is interrupted.14
S. N. Baxi (2009) study
showed that an equal number of students preferred Blackboard based and
multimedia-based lectures. 15
In few studies like Seth (2010) who have compared the
preference for teaching aid between medical students versus dental
students. The medical students have preferred PPT whereas the dental
students preferred the Chalkboard. 16
CONCLUSION:
Combination Teaching aid is most satisfied teaching aid because the
inherent deficiency of one aid is compensated by the other. If individual teaching aids are considered
Blackboard teaching aid is most satisfied because students can follow the
teaching and understand the concept effectively.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
Authors would like to express their gratitude to the
Management, Principal, Facultys and students of Yenepoya nursing college, Nitte Usha Institute of Nursing Sciences, Athena College of
Nursing, Masood College of Nursing, S.C.S college of
Nursing and Pandyarajah Ballal
college of Nursing, Mangalore Karnataka for their whole hearted co-operation
during the study.
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
The author
declare that they have no competing interest
REFERENCES:
1.
Brown G, Atkins M. Effective
Teaching in Higher Education. London, UK: Routledge;
1988. Available from: http://www.itl.usyd.edu/supervision.org/. Accessed May15,
2013
2.
Cannon R. Lecturing, Kensington,
NSW: Higher Education Research and Development Society of Australia; 1988.
Available from: http://www.rsc.org/. Accessed Apr 5, 2013
3.
Hithesh Mishra, Vipin kumar, Pankaj
kumar. Comparison of different teaching methodologies
in a medical college in North India. Ijbamr. Mar
2013; Issue 6(2):464-469
4.
Sahu DR, Supe AN. The art and
science of presentation: 35-mm slides. J
Postgrad Med. 2000;46:280–285.
5.
Estes A, Ressler S, Welch R, Hanus J. Seminar on communication skills. Exceed teaching workshop 2009.
Available from: http://www.asce.org/. Accessed June 10, 2013
6.
Yoa, J. E., Ouyang, J. R., and
Wang, H. (2000). A farewell to the traditional instructional media and
technologies in the new millennium. Available from: http://www.unfi.edu/. Accessed June 22, 2013
7.
Prasad S, Roy B,
Smith M. The art and science of presentation: Electronic presentations. J Postgrad Med.
2000;46:193–198.
8.
Pedras, M. J., and Horton, J. (1996). Using technology to
enhance teacher preparation. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Northwest
Association of Teacher Educators 2009. Available from: http://www.apbr.edu/SRATE. Accessed
June 6, 2013
9.
Ljungdahl, R. T. Technology integration in the teacher
preparation program and public schools in Sam Houston Center for Professional
Development and Educational Partnerships at Sam Houston State University. Dissertation Abstracst
International, 61(8), 3133.
10.
Does PowerPoint
make you stupid? Available at:http://www.sociablemedia.com/PDF/ Accessed Aug 24, 2013
11.
Novelli ELB, Fernandes AAH.
Student’s preferred teaching techniques for biochemistry in biomedicine and
medicine courses. Biochem Mol Biol Educ.
2007;35: 263–266.
12.
Prasad S, Roy B, Smith M. The art and science of presentation:
Electronic presentations. J Postgrad Med. 2000;46:193–198.
13.
Vikas Seth, Prerna Upadhyaya, Mushtaq Ahmad, Virendra Kumar. Impact of Various Lecture Delivery Methods In Pharmacology. EXCLI
Journal. 2010;9:96-101
14.
chaudry R, Dullo P, Gupta U. 2009. “Attitude of 1st
MBBS medical students about two different visual aids in physiology lectures”. Pak Journal Physiology.2005; 5
(2).94-96
15.
S N Baxi, C J Shah, R D Parmar, Parmar, C B Tripathi. “Student’s
perception of different teaching aids in a medical college”. AJHPE. 2009;1(1),
15-16.
16.
Vikas S, Prerna U, Mushtaq A, Vijay M. PowerPoint or chalk and talk:
Perceptions of medical students versus dental students in a medical college in
India. Advances in Medical Education and Practice. 2012; 1:11-16.
Received on 21.09.2013 Modified
on 27.10.2013
Accepted on 30.01.2014
© A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Nur. Edu. & Research 4(1): Jan.-March 2014; Page 131-135