Mr. Hari Krishna G L
Lecturer Cum Inservice Education Coordinator,
Sree Gokulam Nursing
College,
Sree Gokulam Medical College and Research
Foundation, Venjaramoodu, Trivandrum, Kerala- 695607
Corresponding Author Email: harikrishna041@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
The purpose of
this study was to assess the attitude of staff nurses towards organ donation in
a selected hospital in Trivandrum. A sample of 102 staff nurses was recruited
using simple random sampling technique. Data was collected by using a
standardized scale (Organ Donation Attitude Scale). The conceptual framework
was adopted from Theory of Planned behavior by Ajzen.
The majority of the nurses surveyed were belonged to age group less than 30
years (90.2%) with female nurses constituting 83.3% and male nurses
constituting of only 16.7 %. More than half (50.7%) of the nurses were diploma
holders. The study has revealed that the most common source for organ donation
awareness was through news paper (77.4%). The overall attitude with regard to
organ donation was found to be positive 98.04% and a negative attitude
prevailed among 1.96% of the subjects. There was no significant association between
attitude and socio-demographic variables. The findings of the study
demonstrated the need for Nurses
working in ICU’s and Casualty to be well educated and informed about the organ
donation process and the specific roles played by them.
KEY WORDS: Attitude, organ donation, Staff
nurses, Planned behavior, awareness.
INTRODUCTION:
Organ donation is
a fast expanding treatment modality that has come to stay despite the various
misgivings during its inception. Major advances in transplantation have been
achieved since the first cadaver organ transplants in the 1960’s. Today organ
transplantation has developed to great heights and has become an accepted form
of therapy for end stage organ failure. The current potential donor sources
comprise of patients who are rapidly approaching death or have been declared
brain dead.1
In 2008, a total
of 27,281 solid organ transplants were performed of which 21,065 were from
deceased donors. The statistics of 2011 denote that there are currently
1,10,206 awaiting a transplant. It is estimated that approximately 50% of them
will die while on the waiting list.
In India, the
system of national registry for human organ transplantation has been in place
since the inception of The Transplantation of Human Organ Act in 1994. Apart
from the national registry system, each state has a state run registry where
patients on the waiting list for transplants are entered in and matched when a
potential donor is identified. The southern states of India which includes
Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh are said to have one of the
most well run state registry systems in the country for organ donation. 2
A study to explore the attitude of nursing personnel toward donation and the
factors that determine those attitudes in a transplant hospital was done in
Spain. A random sample of 305 nurses in different hospital services were taken
and stratified through the type of service. The study revealed that 63% of the
respondents favored organ donation. The variables that were found to affect the
attitude of nurses are as follows: (1) having a favorable attitude toward
donation of a family member’s organs, (2) knowing the concept of brain death,
(3) having discussed organ donation and transplantation within the family, (4)
having a favorable attitude toward autopsy, (5) fearing mutilation of the body,
(6) a partner’s attitude toward organ donation and transplantation, and (7) the
respondent’s religion.3
The investigator,
on his extensive review of literature has come across many studies in India
that have been done among the medical practitioners in relation to attitude
towards organ donation. The investigator unfortunately had not come across any
study done among Indian nurses with regard to attitude towards organ donation.
The paucity of research within this field has spearheaded the need for the
study. Because of the critical role nurses play in the procurement process,
this descriptive study was undertaken to assess their attitude with regard to
organ donation.
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
A quantitative non
experimental research approach with a descriptive design was used to conduct
the study. The study was conducted in the Nursing service department of Sree Gokulam Medical College, Venjaramoodu. Simple random sampling technique was used to
recruit the subjects. The purpose of the study was
explained, confidentiality was assured and maintained and written informed
consent was obtained from each subject. Tool has 2 parts. Part A includes age, gender, qualification, religion,
area of work, years of experience, experience of caring for patients after
organ donation and sources of organ donation awareness and Part B is a
standardized scale, The Organ Donation Attitude scale, which is a Likert scale that was, developed by Parisi
& Katz and modified by Kent & Owens. The tool has two distinct
components, the first consists of attitudinal statements and the second
addresses a number of issues surrounding organ donation, comprising of 46
statements. Responses ranged from “strongly agree” to “strongly disagree”, with
no neutral option. The potential scores for the Organ Donation Attitude Scale
ranges from 46 to 276. The median score for the questionnaire was considered as
a cut off for analyzing the attitude which was found to be 161. Negative
attitude were those that scored under 161, and positive attitude included all
scores above that point 4,5. Data
collection was done during a single session lasting for 20-30 minutes. Socio
demographic variables were presented with appropriate descriptive statistics.
Chi-square test was used to find out the association between selected variables
and attitude towards organ donation. The Statistical Software SPSS for windows (version 16.0) was employed
for the analysis of data.
RESULTS:
Table 1 highlights
the demographic details of the subjects. It was found that the majority of the
nurses were female (83.3%) with male nurses being only 16.7%. The majority of
the nurses were found to be diploma holders (50.7%). The religion being
practiced by most nurses was found to be Hinduism which accounted for 63.7%. The
nurses who have had prior experience of caring for clients after organ donation
were found to be only 32.4%. It was also found that the majority of the nurses
were found to be belonging to the age group of < 30 years (90.2%).
Table1: Distribution of subjects according
to demographic variable (n = 102)
|
Variables |
Frequency |
% |
|
Age(Years) <30 > 30 |
92 10 |
90.2 9.8 |
|
Years of Experience 0-5 6-10 11-15 |
81 14 7 |
79.4 13.7 6.9 |
|
Gender Female Male |
85 17 |
83.3 16.7 |
|
Education BSc Nursing Post Basic B.Sc (N) |
51 47 4 |
50.7 46.1 3.9 |
|
Cared for Organ donation patient Yes No |
33 69 |
32.4 67.6 |
|
Religion Christian Hindu Muslim |
34 65 3 |
33.3 63.7 2.9 |
Table 2: Distribution
of Nurses according to Sources of Organ donation Awareness (n = 102)
|
Sources of Organ Donation Awareness |
||
|
Sources |
n |
% |
|
Television Yes No |
65 37 |
63.7 36.3 |
|
Nursing Curriculum/Course Yes No |
69 33 |
67.6 32.3 |
|
Newspaper Yes No |
79 23 |
77.4 22.5 |
|
Radio Yes No |
26 76 |
25.4 74.5 |
|
Magazine Yes No |
41 61 |
40.1 59.8 |
|
Others Internet |
2 |
1.9 |
Table 2 depicts
that the majority of the subjects are aware of organ donation through the
newspaper(77.4%).About 67.6% of nurses were aware of organ donation through
nursing curriculum and 63.7% of them were aware of organ donation through the
television. Only 1.9% of nurses felt that the internet was a medium through
which they were made aware of organ donation.
Figure 1:
Attitude of subjects with regard to Organ Donation
Figure 1
illustrates that majority of the Nurses were found to have a positive attitude
98.04 % (n = 100) towards organ donation with negative attitude being only 1.96
% (n = 2).
DISCUSSION:
The present study
reveals that there is a predominantly positive attitude among the subjects
83.9% (n = 426); only 16.10% (n = 82) of the subjects had a negative attitude
towards organ donation (Figure 2). The
findings are consistent with a study where the majority of nursing and medical
student respondents had a positive attitude toward organ donation 98.6%. 6
The present study
findings indicate that there was no significant association between attitude
towards organ donation and demographic variables.
IMPLICATIONS:
Implications for Nursing Practice:
·
Researcher have identified that there is a need for continued and
regular in service educational programme among nurses
on organ donation and aspects related to brain death and the criteria for the
same.
·
Researcher have identified that a clear and concise protocol must
be in place to guide the process of organ donation. This protocol must be
disseminated to all the nurses working in the hospital.
·
Nurses to be equipped with counseling skills especially in the
ICU’s and casualty on counseling regarding organ donation
Implications for Nursing Education:
·
Nursing students need to be educated on organ donation and its
benefits. Training to develop counseling skills to further promote organ
donation should be encouraged.
·
Incorporation of organ donation process and the ethical issues
surrounding it is a pressing need in the curriculum
Implication for Nursing Research:
·
The investigators from the study have identified that there is a
great deal of lacuna in research with regard to organ donation among the Indian
population particularly among nurses. Hence more studies can be done to identify
the needs, barriers and psychological impact with regard to Organ Donation in
India.
LIMITATIONS:
·
The study was conducted in a single setting, hence the generalizability of the study is limited to that setting.
·
The subjects utilized the time after duty hours to complete the
questionnaire, at times it was found that the subjects were hasty to complete
the questionnaire and leave work. This could translate into a false positive as
nurses may not have read the questions and answered patiently.
CONCLUSION:
The purpose of the study was to assess the
attitude of staff nurses towards organ donation. It was found that majority of
nurses hold positive attitude towards organ donation.
It is the need of the hour to encourage
organ donation to meet the demand in the health care sector. Nurses who are the
frontline caregivers play a very significant role in monitoring patients, and
identifying those that are suitable for organ donation. To translate this into
practice, nurses themselves need to believe and accept that organ donation is a
safe and moral act to follow through. It is the nurse who facilitates the
coping of the patients and their families.
REFERENCES:
1.
Henneman EA and Karras
GE. Determining brain death in adults: A guideline for use in critical care. Critical
Care Nurse 24(5); 2004:50-56.
2. Beach PR, Hallett
A.M and Zaruca K. Organ donation after circulatory
death: Vital partnerships. Am J Nurs 111(5); 2011:32
– 39.
3. Zambudio A R et al Attitude of Nursing
staff toward organ donation in a Spanish Hospital with a solid – organ
transplant program. Retrieved from :http://search.proquest.com/health/docview/
227959215/fulltextPDF/133AD16193842DDEC21/2?accountid=37964/2009/19(4):371-377
4. Alam A A.
Public opinion on organ donation in Saudi Arabia. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transpl[Internet]. 2007Mar; 18(1):54 – 9. Retrieved from
http://www.sjkdt.org/article.asp?issn=13192442;2007/vol-18; issue-1
5. Cantarovich, F. Public Opinion and Organ
donation: Suggestions for overcoming Barriers. Ann Transplant.Retrieved
from http://www.mendeley.com/research/public-opinion-organ-donation-suggestions-overcoming-barriers/pdf
2005; 10(1): 22 – 25.
6. Cantwell M and Clifford C.
English Nursing and Medical student’s attitude towards organ donation. J
Adv Nurs 32;
2000: 961 – 968.
Received on 02.08.2014 Modified on 08.09.2014
Accepted on 24.09.2014 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Nur.
Edu. and Research 5(1): Jan.-March 2015; Page105-107
DOI: 10.5958/2349-2996.2015.00022.1