Mrs. Sinmayee Kumari
Devi1, Dr. Sikandar Kumar2
1Asst. Professor,
Dept. of OBG, Lord Jagannath Mission College of
Nursing, Rasulgarh-10, Bhubaneswar, Odisha
2Vice Principal, Lord
Jagannath Mission College of Nursing, Rasulgarh-10,
Bhubaneswar, Odisha
Corresponding
Author Email: sinmayee.devi@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
A quasi experimental study with pre and post test with without control
group design was under taken in HI-TECH school of nursing, BBSR to assess the effectiveness
of SIM regarding high risk pregnancy on knowledge among the ANM students. 42
ANM students were selected by simple random sampling technique and Data was
collected by using closed ended questionnaire from Dt-27.02.2014 to
Dt-13.03.2014 and collected data were analyzed by using descriptive and
inferential statistics. Findings revealed that highest percentage 50% of the
ANM students were in the age group of 18-20 years. All were female and
unmarried Majorities 98% of them are Hindus and 2% are Christians. The overall
pre test mean score was (9.42±6.8) which is 31% of the total score reveals poor
knowledge where as it was (16.85±9.7) which is 56% in posttest revealing 25% of
enhancement knowledge score. Area wise highest post test mean score (4.9±5.2)
which is 49% was obtained for the area of “risk factor” where as the lowest
post test mean score (1.4±1.6) which is 46.6% was obtained for the area of
“complication”. Highly significant
(p<0.01) difference was found between pre and post test knowledge scores and
no significant (p>0.05) association was found between post test knowledge
scores in relation to demographic variables of ANM students.
KEYWORDS: High risk pregnancy, Auxiliary nurses and midwifery student, self
instructional module.
INTRODUCTION:
High risk pregnancy
refers to a pregnancy in which the fetus has a higher than average chance of
experiencing morbidity or mortality. High risk pregnancy is one which is
complicated by factor or factors that adversely affects the pregnancy outcome,
maternal or perinatal or both. All pregnancy and
deliveries are potentially at risk. However there are certain categories of
pregnancies where the mother, the foetus or the
neonate is in high risk. About 20-30% belongs to this category. If we desire to
improve obstetric results, this group must be identified and given extra care (Dutta D.C, 2004).
They are generally
associated with inadequate prenatal care, previous obstetrical history (such as
spontaneous abortion), preexisting maternal disease, pregnancy induced disease
(such as gestational hypertension), multiple pregnancy and maternal age below
17 yr or above 35yr.The risk factors may be pre-existing prior or at the time
of first antenatal visit or may develop subsequently in the ongoing pregnancy
labor or pueriperium (Rao Kamini, 2011).
A woman is considered to have a high-risk pregnancy when
health concerns exist that may threaten the natural course of the development
or birth of the baby, or that pose a risk to the mother. In such cases, the
mother may need special care, more tests and possibly medication to ensure that
she can carry the baby safely through to delivery. While pregnancy is a natural
condition, it can be complicated even in healthy woman's body because of
changes in blood volume, hormone balance, pressure, the physical burden of
pregnancy etc. Underlying medical conditions can add even more stress, while
complications caused by pregnancy itself (such as preeclampsia or gestational
diabetes) can turn a normal pregnancy into a high-risk pregnancy. Most
high-risk pregnancies still end with a healthy mother and child; it is still
true that six out of 100,000 births in the United States, the mother die, 16
babies in every 1,000 deliveries also die before, during, or after birth. A
pre-pregnancy visit with a healthcare provider is especially important for a
woman who has a medical problem.
A woman who has not had a pre-pregnancy visit should
contact a healthcare provider as soon as she learns she is pregnant. Often, the
provider will schedule the first prenatal visit within a day or two, instead of
waiting until 8-10 weeks of pregnancy. This is because certain medical
conditions can increase the risk of miscarriage. The provider has to be sure
that any medication is adjusted properly to increase the chance of having a
successful pregnancy. In addition a woman with a high-risk pregnancy may be
referred to a prenatal care center need the expert advice (Christopher Murray
et al, 2008).
Women die from a wide range of complications in pregnancy, childbirth or
the postpartum period. Most of these complications develop because of their
pregnant status and some because pregnancy aggravated an existing disease. The
four major killers are: severe bleeding (mostly bleeding postpartum),
infections (also mostly soon after delivery), hypertensive disorders in
pregnancy (eclampsia) and obstructed labour. Complications after unsafe abortion cause 13% of
maternal deaths. Globally, about 80% of maternal deaths are due to these
causes. Among the indirect causes (20%) of maternal death are diseases that
complicate pregnancy or are aggravated by pregnancy, such as malaria, anemia
and HIV. Women also die because of poor health at conception and a lack of
adequate care needed for the healthy outcome of the pregnancy for themselves
and their babies.
The first step for avoiding maternal deaths is to ensure that women have
access to family planning and safe abortion. This will reduce unwanted
pregnancies and unsafe abortions. The women who continue pregnancies need care
during this critical period for their health and for the health of the babies
they are bearing. Most maternal deaths are avoidable, as the health care
solutions to prevent or manage the complications are well known. Since
complications are not predictable, all women need care from skilled health
professionals, especially at birth, when rapid treatment can make the
difference between life and death. For instance, severe bleeding after birth
can kill even a healthy woman within two hours if she is unattended. Injecting
the drug oxytocin immediately after childbirth
reduces the risk of bleeding very effectively (WHO, 2007).
The perinatal mortality rate has often been
used as an index of the level of development in a community. It not only
reflects the socioeconomic status, educational level and cultural background of
the mother but also comments on the quality of medical care provided to the
mother and her neonate. A number of biological and social factors during
pregnancy influence the perinatal mortality. Although
only 10-30% of the mothers seen in antenatal period can be classified as high
risk they account for 70-80% of perinatal mortality
and morbidity. Age, parity, social class and past obstetric history are only
some of the factors that should be taken into account while assessing the risk for
any pregnant woman. Early identification of the factors that influence perinatal mortality followed by proper management and
therapy can frequently modify or prevent a poor perinatal
outcome.
High-tech maternal and child health care (as
electronic foetal monitoring, portable ultrasonography, intensive neonatal care units at PHC level etc) as is available in the West
is not possible in rural India where poverty, ignorance and illiteracy prevail.
Hence, a need for a simplified and less invasive method for early detection of
high risk pregnancy is needed. According to Sundarka
and Kacchap1 in our
country where there is a lack of facility at each level a scoring system would
be a cost effective and easily accessible method to screen the high risk
pregnancy and to estimate the net perinatal outcome.
The risk scoring provides a formalized method of recognizing, documenting and
cumulating antepartum and intrapartum
factors in order to predict the later complications for mother and her foetus.
High risk pregnancy requires exemplary individualised care and special attention as this group is
responsible for maximum perinatal mortality and
morbidity even though they form a small proportion of the entire population.
Despite recent
advances in modern obstetrics and neonatal care India, is still facing a high
(33/1000) perinatal mortality rate compared to 5-10
per 1000 live births in developed countries. 70%-80% of perinatal
mortality in developing countries including India is accounted for by the
mothers falling in the high risk category. Each year more than 500,000 women
die from pregnancy related causes, 99% of these in developing countries, perinatal mortality is one of the most sensitive indices of
maternal and child health. At the beginning of this millennium in year 2000,189
countries and 23 international health agencies had pledged to reduce the child
under -5 mortality by 2/3 and maternal mortality by 3/4 by 2015. Perinatal mortality rate of India in 2007 was 37/1000 live
birth. In 2002-2005 it was 301/100000 live birth and current MMR of India in
2009 is 250/1,00000 live births. One of
the reasons for this dismal performance is failure to identify the foetus at risk in time. Perinatal
outcome can be changed significantly by early detection followed by special intensive
care of high risk pregnancies by health care providers (Samiya
M,2008).
It is an accepted
truth that the probability of undergoing a high risk pregnancy increases with
increasing maternal age. Even the mother who have in the past experienced multiple
miscarriages, still births, neonatal deaths or may be preterm deliveries also
stand a chance to suffer from high risk pregnancy (WHO,2004). Most women in the
world do not have access to the health care and health education services they
need during pregnancy. In many developing countries, complications of pregnancy
and child birth are the leading cause of death among women of reproductive age.
More than one women every minute and 6lakhs women every year die during
pregnancy (Pieper PG, 2011).
A study was conducted on 750 women to determine the profile of high-risk
pregnancy in El-Mansoura city. The study revealed that among all women,
63.8% of the samples were at a high-risk, while 25.0 % at a moderate-risk and
only 11.2% were at low-risk. About 70.0% of the high-risk pregnant women were
in their third trimester followed by 23.0% in the second trimester and only
7.1% were in the first trimester. About
5.9% of the women were at a high-risk because of polluted housing conditions,
1.9% had heart diseases, 5.2% because of diabetes mellitus, 4.2% had
hypertension and 14.9% had undergone previous cesarean section. 14.8% women
were at moderate risk because of their
illiteracy, 29.2% of them for being short, 14.7% and 10.6% were teenagers or
over 35 years of age respectively, 12.6% had a history of gestational diabetes
and 32.8% had anemia, 23.2% had urinary tract infection, 16.9% had albuminuria, and 12.0% had glucoseuria.
Finally, identifying the profile of high -risk pregnant women is mandatory (Yassin S.A, 2005).
A study was conducted
in the Udupi district to determine the effectiveness
of an information booklet on “Prevention of high risk pregnancy”. 30 primigravid women were taken as a sample and the result
indicated that the post-test knowledge score was higher (M=33) than the mean
pre-test knowledge score (M=16.83). This indicated that the administration of
an information booklet was effective in increasing the knowledge of primigravid women (Thresia C.M,
2006).
If we desire to improve our obstetric results, the high risk case should
be identified and given proper antenatal, intranatal
and neonatal care by the health care providers. So, all the health care
personnel should be competent enough to handle such type of cases. Hence, here
the researcher took interest do the study among ANM student to assess the
knowledge regarding identification of high risk pregnancy and its management
and also to educate them by providing information booklet.
OBJECTIVES:
1) To assess the:-
Ø Knowledge among
ANM students regarding identification and management of high risk pregnancy
before implementing the SIM.
Ø Effectiveness
of SIM on the knowledge of ANM Students regarding the identification and
management of high risk pregnancy.
2)
To find out the association between post test
knowledge score with their selected demographic variables.
HYPOTHESIS:
H0: There
will be no significant difference between pretest and post test knowledge
scores ANM students regarding high risk pregnancy.
H1: There
will be no association between the post test knowledge scores with their selected demographic variable
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
Research design and
approach
A quasi- experimental
design, where pre and post test without control group and evaluative approach
was used.
O1--------X----------O2
O2- O1=E
The symbol used are
explained as follows
O1 - Pretest = Knowledge scores of ANM students regarding identification and
management of high risk pregnancy before implementing self instructional
module.
X - Treatment
= presentation of self instructional module regarding identification and
management of high risk pregnancy
O2 - Post test = Knowledge scores of ANM students regarding identification and
management of high risk pregnancy after implementing self instructional module.
E = Effectiveness of self instructional module.
Setting of the study:
The study was
conducted in Hi-tech School of nursing , Rasulgarh,
Bhubaneswar .
Sample and Sampling
Technique:
42 ANM students were
selected by simple random sampling techniques is a probability sampling
technique where the researcher given equal chance to all the participant.
Description of the tool:
After an extensive
review, author developed the tool, based on objectives.
The tool has 2
sections i.e , Section “A” and Section “B”
·
Section “A” consists of demographic variable
of ANM students]
·
Section “B” consists of knowledge
questionnaire regarding identification of high risk pregnancy and its
management.
Validity and Reliability:
Validity refers to the degree to which an
instrument measures what it is supposed to measure. Content validity concerns
the degree to which an instrument has appropriate sample of items for the
construct being measured and adequately covers the construct domain. The
content validity of the tool was
established from various experts in field of obstetrics, obstetrics and
gynecological nursing, community health nursing and statistics. Suggestions
were given by the experts and the tool was modified accordingly.
Table-1: Overall and
Area wise comparison of mean SD and mean% of pre and post test knowledge score
of ANM students regarding high risk pregnancy
Sl. No. |
Area |
Max. score |
Pretest |
Post-test |
Effectiveness |
||||
Mean |
SD |
Mean% |
Mean |
SD |
Mean% |
||||
1 |
Introduction
|
04 |
2.3 |
2.49 |
57.5 |
3.07 |
3.19 |
76.75 |
19.25 |
2 |
Risk
factor |
10 |
2.8 |
3.17 |
28 |
4.9 |
5.2 |
49 |
21 |
3 |
Assessment
and screening |
08 |
2.2 |
2.62 |
27.5 |
4.61 |
5 |
57.62 |
30.12 |
4 |
Complication
|
03 |
0.6 |
0.93 |
20 |
1.4 |
1.6 |
46.6 |
26.6 |
5 |
Management
|
05 |
1.3 |
1.95 |
26 |
2.83 |
3.12 |
56.6 |
30.6 |
Over all |
30 |
9.42 |
6.8 |
31 |
16.85 |
9.7 |
56 |
25 |
Reliability of the tool was tested by split
half method (odd-even) by using Karl–Pearsons’s correlation
coefficient formula and spearman brown formula was used to find out the
reliability of the tool, the r value was 0.92 and it was found that the tool
was more reliable.
Data collection procedure
Prior to the data collection, the permission
was obtained from the principal of Hi-tech school of nursing and verbal
informed consent was taken from the respondent. Pretest was conducted followed
by administration of SIM. and post test was done after 7 days.
Planned
data analysis
The collected data were organized, tabulated
and analyzed by using descriptive and inferential statistics.
Findings
Distribution of ANM students according to
their demographic variables reveals that Highest percentage (50%) of the ANM
students were in the age group of 18-20 years, All the ANM students (100%) were
female, 97.6% Hindu and 2.3% Christian.
Table:1- Depicts
that overall pretest knowledge score was
(9.42±6.8) which is 31% where as post
test knowledge score was (16.85±9.7) which is 56%, which shows the effectiveness of SIM on knowledge
regarding identification of high risk pregnancy and its management among the ANM students.
Fig- 1: Comparison of level of knowledge of pre and post test scores of
the ANM students regarding high risk pregnancy
Level of knowledge
Table-2: Comparison of pre and post test knowledge score
of ANM students regarding identification and management of high risk pregnancy
Area |
‘Z’ value |
Level of significance |
Introduction |
4.11 |
Highly significant |
Risk factor |
6.02 |
Highly significant |
Assessment and screening |
10.43 |
Highly significant |
Complication |
3.3 |
Highly significant |
Management |
5.1 |
Highly significant |
“Z” test was
calculated which shows highly significant difference between pretest and
posttest. Hence stated null hypothesis is rejected (P<0.01) and statistical
hypothesis is accepted. Thus, the difference observed in the mean score value
of pretest and posttest were true difference and not by chance .Thus, it can be
interpreted that self Instructional module was effective for all areas.
c2 was
computed to find out the association between the post test KS and the
demographic variables of the ANM students and Findings reveal that there was no
significant association between KS of students when compared with their
demographic variable (P>0.05). Hence, it can be interpreted that the
difference in mean score related to the all demographic variables were only by
chance not true and null hypothesis was accepted.
CONCLUSION:
From the finding of the present study it can be concluded that SIM
regarding high risk pregnancy among ANM students was effective to improve the
knowledge of ANM students. Prior to implementation of SIM, the ANM students had
poor knowledge 31% after implementation of SIM students had good knowledge 56
regarding identification of high risk pregnancy and its management with the
difference in mean percentage of 25% which shows the effectiveness of SIM.
Highly significant difference was found between pre and post test knowledge score
(p<0.01) and No significance association was found between the posttest
knowledge score when compared with demographic variables of ANM students
(p<0.05s).
IMPLICATIONS:
Nursing Services:
·
The content of the SIM will help the ANM
students working in the hospital and community for reinforcing their knowledge
on high risk pregnancy.
·
The findings will help the nursing personnel
to assess the risk condition which requires knowledge on high risk pregnancy to
save the life of the mother.
Nursing education:
·
The nurse educator can use the SIM to teach
the students about how to identify a high risk pregnancy.
·
The findings will help the nurse to give more
importance for planning and organizing the SIM to improve knowledge of clinical
practice of the students.
Nursing research:
·
The findings can be utilized for conducting
research on the effectiveness of SIM on various aspect of nursing.
·
The large scale study can be done for
replication to standardized the SIM on high risk pregnancy.
·
Use of research findings should become the
part of quality assurance evaluate to enhance individual profession as a whole.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
·
A large scale study can be carried out to
generalized the findings.
·
A similar study can be conducted by using
VATM for educating the ANM students.
REFERENCES:
1.
Dr Christopher Murray et al, “Maternal mortality rate in
India”, Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation,
University of Washington 2008.
2.
Dutta DC.
Textbook of Obstetrics. 5th edition. Calcutta: New Central Book
Agency (P) Ltd. 2001.
3.
Dutta S and Das
XS, “Identification of high risk mothers by a scoring system and it’s
correlation with perinatal outcome”, Journal of Obstet Gynaecol India. 1990; 40:
181-190.
4.
El Daba AA, Amr YM, Marouf HM, Mostafa M, “Retrospective study of maternal mortality in a
tertiary hospital in Egypt.” Anesthesia Essays Research 2010; 4:29-32.
5.
Fraser DM, Cooper MA. Myles Textbook for
Midwives. 14th edition. China: Churchill Livingstone. 2003.
6.
R. V. Bardale MD
and P. G. Dixit MD, “Factors causing high risk pregnancy and to recognize cause
of death.” Department of Forensic Medicine, Govt. Medical College and Hospital,
Nagpur, India 2006.
7.
Rajaeefard A, Mohammadi M, Choobineh A. Preterm delivery risk factors: a prevention strategy in Shiraz, Islamic
Republic of Iran. East Mediterranean Health Journal. 2007 May-Jun;
13(3):551-9.
8.
Shahzada J. Malik and Nisar A. Mir, “identify
the preventable factors in high risk pregnancy”, Journal of obstetrics and gynecology
research, May 2010.
9.
Stark MA. Directed attention in normal and high-risk
pregnancy. Journal of Obstetrics Gynecology and Neonatal Nursing. 2006
Mar-Apr; 35(2):241-9.
10. UNFPA: Population issues: Safe Motherhood:
Maternal Mortality; [online] available from: http//www.unfpa.org/mothers/statistics.htm.Oct 2007.
11.
Vertika Kishore, Man M Misro, and Deoki Nandan, “Knowledge of
health care workers regarding risk pregnancy”, Indian Journal of Community
Medicine, 2010 January; 35(1): 46–51
12.
Yassin SA, Gamal El-Deen AA, Emam MA, Omer AK. The profile of high-risk pregnancy in El-Mansoura city. Journal of Egypt Public Health
Association. 2005; 80(5-6):687-706.
Received on
14.08.2014 Modified on 08.09.2014
Accepted on
24.09.2014 © A&V Publication all
right reserved
Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research 5(1):
Jan.-March 2015; Page146-150
DOI: 10.5958/2349-2996.2015.00031.2