Effectiveness of Coma Stimulation Therapy on Traumatic Brain Injury patients in a Government hospital setup –A Feasibility Study

 

Deiva.K1, Vijayalakshmi.S2, Suseela.T3

1,2,3 Clinical Instructor, college of nursing, National Institute Of Mental Health And Neurosciences (NIMHANS),Instituteof National Importance (INI), Hosur Road, Bangalore – 560029.Karnataka

*Corresponding Author Email:deiva_77@yahoo.com

 

ABSTRACT:

Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) is one of the leading causes of morbidity, mortality and disability in India (Gururaj, 2002). With this background Arumugam et, al (2013) carried out a research by structured multimodal coma stimulation therapy is reported to be beneficial for these patients. In the current study the effect of multimodal sensory stimulation was evaluated using JFK Coma Recovery Scale- Revised (2004) and GCS in patients with TBI through pre and post-test experimental research design. This study was an attempt to bring the effectiveness nursing interventions for the patients with TBI in a hospital setup and brought good outcome.  The current study carried out two follow-ups and the post test score revealed there was significant improvement in the scores of GCS and CRS. Hence the current study infers that nursing intervention also plays a role in the person with TBI in a hospital setup.

 

KEYWORDS:Coma Stimulation Therapy, Nursing Intervention, Traumatic Brain Injury.


 

 

INTRODUCTION:

Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) is one of the leading causes of morbidity, mortality and disability in India (Gururaj, 2002)1. With this background Arumugam et, al (2013) carried out a research by structured multimodal coma stimulation therapy is reported to be beneficial for these patients2. Traumatic brain injury (TBI) refers to the potential for significant injury to the brain parenchyma due to head trauma. Epidemiological surveillance reveals that there is a changing nature of TBI over time. Glasgow Comma Scale (GCS) is generally used to classify the TBI as mild or moderate in majority of the cases (Annoni et al., 1992).3  The center for Disease Control and Prevention has described that TBI was the “silent epidemic,” of developed nations.

 

India was reported to have the highest rates of intracranial injury from road traffic accidents, falls and other injuries. In India RTI occurs one in every minute and RTI related death takes place in every 4 minutes. According to the World Health Organization TBI would surpass many other diseases as the major cause of death and disability by the year 2020. Gruraj (2008) reported that TBI is a leading cause of mortality, morbidity, and socioeconomic losses in India. While we look at globally, the incidence is increasing, mainly due to greater use of motor vehicles in low- and middle-income countries.4

 

MATERIAL AND METHODS:

The current object of the study had the aim of to find the effectiveness of Coma Stimulation Therapy and its feasibility. There were two objectives 1. To assess the GCS and CRS scores on TBI patients. 2. To assess the effectiveness of Coma Stimulation Therapy. The study population consisted of 30 patients with traumatic brain injury who were admitted at Central Government Teaching Hospital, in Bangalore, Karnataka. The study group consisted of 15 patients in the Experimental group and 15 patients in the Control group selected through purposive sampling method.

 

The current study adapted quasi experimental research design. Total duration of the study was one month. Patient in experimental group were given coma stimulation therapy while those in control group received only as usual treatment from the ward and they did not receive any coma stimulation therapy.

 

The studies used standardized scale namely, Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) Total score is 15 it has three components eye response(4),verbal response(5),motor response(6) and Coma Recovery Scale (CRS) revised 2004. The total score is 23 it has five sub scale i.s auditory function scale(4), visual function scale(5), motor function scale(6), oromotor /verbal function scale(3), communication scale(2), arousal scale(3).  It was assessed before and after 1stand 2nd week as per the current study protocol. The study included the patients who had TBI with comatose status, 72 hours after TBI and GCS <8. The study excluded the medically unstable patients, comatose patients on ventilation, pediatric and medical comatose patients. Ethical consideration were taken care by written consent was obtained from the family members, the researchers got permission from head of the department of Neuro Surgery and Nursing.

 

TREATMENT PROCEDURE:

The protocol of stimulation therapy validated by experts. Coma stimulation was given using a coma kit, which was prepared by locally available and easily affordable materials.

 

Procedure for coma stimulation therapy:

The researcher had selected few of the coma stimulation therapy namely, Auditory, Olfactory, Visual and Tactile stimulus.

 

Auditory stimulation:

The stimulus was presented for 5 to 10 seconds, twice, with a 3 second interval between each stimulus, on right side, then on left side through the relative’s voice through the caretakers whomever were available.

 

Tactile stimulation:

Stimulus was presented for 10 seconds, twice with a 3 second interval between each stimulus through cotton ball and gentle touch for 10 seconds from to right and left upper extremities, then right and left lower extremities.

 

Olfactory Stimulation:

Stimulus was presented for 10 seconds, twice, with a 3 second interval between each stimulus through coffee powder.

Visual Stimulation:

Stimulus was presented for 5 to 10 seconds, twice, with a 3 second interval between each stimulus. It was repeated right and left sides then up and down.

 

Statistical analysis:

Mean median and standard deviation, the Man – Whitney U test and Friedman test and Chi square test were used.

 

RESULTS:

Section 1:Demographic characteristics:

The age was divided in to two groups for statistical analysis, wherein more than half of them belong to the age group of 35 years below. Three fourth of the subject belong to male gender (77%). Fifty three percent of the subjects had undergone primary level of education. The cause of TBI showed that the vehicle accident constituted sixty seven percent and the rest are like falling, hitting or assault. Seventy percent of the subjects had open type of TBI.


Section 2: Table 1: GCS scores in Experimental group ( n= 9 )

GCS Score

N

Mean

Std. Deviation

(χ2) Test df (2)

Level of significance

GCS1d

9

5.89

1.054

 

 

GCS7d

9

5.89

1.054

18.00

 Significant

GCS14d

9

7.22

1.202

 

 

(p<0.05)

 

Table:1 shows that GCS score in experimental group. The Chi square test revealed that there was significant difference in Experimental group in GCS at 14th day (p<.0.05).

 

Table 2: GCS scores in Control group (n=11)

GCS Score

N

Mean

Std. Deviation

(χ2) Test df (2)

Level of significance

GCS1d

11

5.82

.874

 

 

GCS7d

11

5.82

.874

6.000

Non significant

GCS14d

11

6.36

1.206

 

 

(p<0.05)

 

Table:2 depicts that GCS score in control group. The Chi square test revealed that there was no significant difference in control group in GCS at 14th day (p<.0.05).

Table 3:CRS scores in Experimental group:

CRS Score

N

Mean

Std. Deviation

 (χ2) Testdf (2)

Level of significance

CRS 1d

9

4.56

1.130

 

 

CRS 7d

9

5.11

1.900

16.800

significant

CRS 14d

9

8.44

1.667

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

(p<0.001)

 

Table:3 reveals that CRS score in experimental group. The Chi square test revealed that there was significant difference in Experimental group in CRS at 14th day (p<.0.001).

 

Table 4: CRS scores in Control group

CRS Score

N

Mean

Std. Deviation

(χ2) Test df (2)

Level of Significance

CRS 1d

11

5.00

1.732

 

 

CRS 7d

CRS 14d

11

11

5.55

5.91

1.809

1.514

8.588

Non significant

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

(p<0.001)

 

Table:4 shows that CRS score in control group. The Chi square test revealed that there was no significant difference in Control group in CRS at 14th day (p<.0.001}.

 

Table 5: Comparison of GCS between Experimental and Control Group.

GCS

 

Mean

SD

(χ2) Test

Level of significance

1st Day

Experimental group (N=9)

5.89

1.054

 

97.500

Non significant

Control group

5.82

.874

7th Day

Experimental group

5.89

1.054

67.500

Non significant

Control group

5.82

.874

14th Day

Experimental group

7.22

1.202

30.000

Non significant

Control group

6.36

1.206

p<0.05

 

Table: 5 reveals that Comparison of GCS between Experimental and Control group .In GCS while comparing the Experimental group and Control group there was no significant difference found between the groups.

 

Table:6 Comparison of CRS between  Experimental and Control group

CRS

 

Mean

SD

 (χ2) Test

Level of significance

1st Day

Experimental group (N=9)

4.56

1.130

80.500

Non significant

Control group(11)

5.00

1.732

7th Day

Experimental group

5.11

1.900

41.500

significant

Control group

5.55

1.809

14th Day

Experimental group

8.44

1.667

13.500

significant

Control group

5.91

1.514

*P<0.05

 


Table:6 depicts that Comparison of CRS between Experimental and Control group. In CRS while comparing the Experimental and Control group there was a significant difference found between the groups on 7th and 14th day.

 

DISCUSSION:

The study consisted of thirty patients with TBI, which had 15 patients in treatment group Experimental group and another 15 patients in control group. But the researchers were able to retain only for nine patients in for coma stimulation therapy (CST) and in eleven in control group. The reason for the drop was due to the patients became worse and they were supported with ventilator (N), death (1) and further general hospital treatment. The above finding would be supported with the following findings that, Sazbon (1993) reported that in a trail of 100 patients.

 

There were only 20 patients recovered consciousness within five months, 31 had died by six months, and 49 remained un conscious for remaining of their life and only seven patients were alive after 72 months of follow up. And further Sazbon (1993) reported that the outcome for the patients with coma or vegetative state with non-traumatic brain injury was worse than that of with traumatic brain injury.5

 

Group Comparison:

The current study findings revealed that the overall GCS scores of Experimental group revealed that there were no significant improvement at first and seventh day but that there was a significant improvement (p<0.05) in Experimental group at 14th day. The present study finding was supported by Mandeep (2012) reported that there were no significant improvement in day one but the study revealed that there were significant improvement in 7th(6.33±1.04) and 14th(8.46 ± 0.91) day in the experimental group.

 

The overall scores of GCS were not significant while comparing with the Experimental and Control group.. While comparing the overall CRS scores between treatment group and the treatment as usual group, the score were significantly higher in 14th day with coma stimulation therapy for the Experimental group than with the Control group with the p <0.05. The current study findings corroborated with findings of Mandeep (2012) that CRS (9.66±1.83) were significantly higher in experimental group than the control group 6

 

STRENGTH AND LIMITATION OF THE STUDY:

Nursing professionals which includes the student population can do this coma stimulation therapy as a nursing procedure as part of their daily routine with all the other nursing procedures so that the deserving patients with TBI would get the maximum benefits without having additional staffing. Another setback to the study was drop outs that also have affected the effectiveness of the study findings. The duration of the coma stimulation could have been little higher. But studies have reported that increase in the duration and intensity would hinder the patient’s prognosis. The study was carried out in the hospital set up with the small sample hence the study findings cannot be generalized. The study has paved the way for patients with TBI who probably undergoing sensory deprivation; they would get the benefit of recovering from the coma through coma stimulation therapy the nursing professionals.

 

CONCLUSION:

The researchers planned to carry out the coma stimulation therapy by taking in to consideration with previous researches and replicated the previous findings and proved the feasibility of carrying out the coma stimulation therapy in a clinical setting with the low cost materials and staffs already been employed. Hence the study findings could be replicated in a larger sample with a longer duration through random sampling so as to get the statistically significant results in overall scores and in the domains scores.

 

REFERENCES:

1.     Gururaj G. Epidemiology of traumatic brain injuries: Indian scenario. Neurol Res 2002; 24:24–28. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11783750.

2.     Arumugam, G., Brammatha., Effect of right side median nerve stimulation along with multi-sensory coma stimulation program on level of consciousness and neuro behavioral function among diffuse axonal injury patients. -an experimental study. International Journal of Physiotherapy and Research 2013 Aug;1(3):83-87.

3.     Annoni, J. M., Beer, S., and Kesselring, J. Severe traumatic brain injury—epidemiology and outcome after 3 years. Disability and Rehabilitation: An International, Multidisciplinary Journal, (1992). 14(1), 23-26.https //www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov › ncbi › literature.

4.     Gururaj G. Road traffic deaths, injuries and disabilities in India: current scenario. Natl Med J India 2008;21:14–20. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18472698.

5.     Sazbon et al. Course and outcome of patients in vegetative state of nontraumatic aetiology. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 1993. 56:407–9.

6.     Mandeep., Kumar P Effectiveness of Early Intervention of Coma Arousal Therapy in Traumatic Head Injury Patients. International Journal of Head and Neck Surgery (2012) Sep-Dec3(3):137.

 

 

 

 

 

Received on 27.03.2017                Modified on 01.04.2017

Accepted on 01.05.2017                © A&V Publications all right reserved

Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research.2017; 7(4): 569-572.

DOI:10.5958/2349-2996.2017.00110.0