A Descriptive Study to determine the Contributing Factors for ICU Stress and to Assess the level of Stress among patients admitted in ICU

 

Dr. K. Priscilla

Professor, Medical Surgical Nursing Department, CSI Jeyaraj Annapackiam College of Nursing, Jonespuram, Pasumalai, Madurai – 625004

*Corresponding Author Email: asa.raja@yahoo.com

 

ABSTRACT:

This present study was done to determine the contributing factors for ICU stress and to assess the level of stress among patients admitted in ICU. A descriptive design was adopted. A total of 100 clients admitted in ICU were selected by using purposive sampling technique. Contributing factors for ICU stress was assessed by modified Environmental Stressor Questionnaire (ESQ) and level of stress was assessed by modified stress scale. Environmental stressor questionnaire items were given scoring as per the response for each item, the mean % is worked out (actual score / maximum possible score) x 100. Modified stress scale was scaled as low level stress (0-33%) moderate level stress (34%-67%) & high level stress (68%-100%). The research findings revealed that the top mean score of stressors were observing treatment that are administered to other patients (98.75%), not knowing exactly where they are (98.25%), not knowing what is the time (97.25%), and listening to the ringing of telephone (94.75%), missing the spouse (or) partner (94.50%) etc. With regards to level of stress 54(54%) samples had high level stress, 36(36%) samples had moderate level of stress & 10(10%) samples had low level stress.

 

KEYWORDS: ICU stress, stressors.

 

 


INTRODUCTION:

Any situation that gives special or psychological demands upon a person results in stress which is unbalances his/her equilibrium. Intensive care unit is a specialized unit which provides complex care to patients with serious injury or illness. Kimberly R Boer1 determined the prevalence of stress disorder in patients admitted in ICU. The result revealed that stress disorders were found in 24% of the respondents.

 

The stress disorder was 4.3 times higher in surgical patients. Andreas valentine2 described that the intensive care patients exposed to complex and invasive process of care which resulted in stress and unfavourable outcome in critically ill patients.

 

Yoel Donchin3 stated that, ICU includes an allay of technology to support medical care. The environment does not concentrate on human factors, human performance, but Lighting, ambient noise, tubing, being alone are the factors contributed to the stress disorder.

 

BACKGROUND:

Hospital is a place which originate in anxiety. There may be cycles of anxiety, uncertainty and lack of communication which affect the well being of the client. ICU is a highly specified and complex area of a hospital which is specifically designed, furnished and equipped.

 

Sepideh Olausson4 Phenomenological study on experience of ICU clients revealed that ICU setting is a place of care for critically ill patients with complex and multi dimensional phenomenon. The patients experience ICU as a place of vulnerability a place in between a place of trust and security, a life affirming place, a place of tender care.

 

About five million patients stay in an intensive care unit of United States had symptoms of stress. It is found that patients with abdominal surgeries and prolong stay were the risk to develop stress disorders. But it is important that the ICU survivors must be screened for stress or low mood5.

 

Recent epidemiological study6 among patients admitted in the trauma intensive care unit in Tokyo showed that most of the patients in the intensive care unit met the stressor criterion. The environmental factors such as moaning, crying, sights of blood, vomits and excreta were the major contributing factors of ICU stress.

 

Over whelming psychological stress may cause temporary (transient) and long lasting (chronic) symptoms of serious psychiatric illness. Un controllable, unpredictable and persistent stress has its consequences on physical and mental health, thus results in clinical depression and anxiety7.

 

Patients in critical care unit face great amount of stress which should be recognized by the health professionals. Humanizing the ICU environment will potentially avert adverse effect on patients8. Amounting body of research suggest that the positive environment could improve healing and healing process of patients. The nurse in the ICU is referred as an environment activist and “tamer of technology” who can create a positive healing environment for patients and family members.

 

STATEMENT:

A descriptive study to determine the contributing factors for ICU stress and to assess the level of stress among patients admitted in ICU.

 

OBJECTIVES:

1.     To find out the contributing factors for stress among patients admitted in ICU.

2.     To assess the level of stress among patients admitted in ICU.

3.     To find out the association between level of stress among patients admitted in ICU with their selected clinical characteristics of patients.

 

CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK:

It was based on Neuman’s System Model. It comprised of Basic structures lines of resistance, Normal line of defense, Flexible line of defense stressor, Reaction, Reconstitution and Preventino.

 

MATERIALS AND METHODS:

Research Approach:

Quantitative approach was adopted.

 

Research Design:

Descriptive design.

 

Setting of the study:

Setting I:

Devadoss Multispeciality Hospital Madurai. It is a 150 bedded hospital.

 

Setting II:

Madurai Institute of Traumatology (MIOT) Madurai. It is a 60 bedded hospital.

 

Sample size:

Comprised of 100 samples.

 

Sampling technique:

Convenience sampling technique was used.

 

Sampling criteria:

Inclusion Criteria:

·       Patients who were admitted in ICU after general abdominal & orthopedic surgery.

·       Patients who have spent minimum 24 hours of time in ICU.

·       Both male and female patients were included.

 

Exclusion Criteria:

·       Patients who already developed ICU delirium / ICU psychosis.

·       Patients who are critically ill / on mechanical ventilator.

 

Data Collection Instruments:

The tool was developed by the researcher.

 

Part I:

Demographic variables and clinical characteristics of patients.

 

Part 2:

Modified Environmental Stressor Questionnaire (ESQ)

 

Part 3:

Modified Stress Scale.

 

Data collection Instruments:

Testing of the Tool:

Validity:

To ensure the content validity the instruments were given to 13 experts in the field of medicine, nursing, ….. etc.

Reliability:

Tool I:     Modified environmental stressor questionnaire

Dimensions

No. of Items

N

Alpha reliability

Validity

Overall

50

100

0.810

0.900

 

Tool II: Modified stress scale

Dimensions

No. of Items

N

Alpha reliability

Validity

Overall

29

100

0.827

0.909

 

Data collection procedure:

Formal permission was obtained from concerned authority of Devadoss Multispeciality Hospital & MIOT. The researcher got an informed consent from the study subjects. First the investigator assessed the contributing factors for ICU stress by Modified Environmental Stressor Questionnaire (ESQ). Simultaneously the level of stress was assessed by using modified stress scale.

 

Table I: Ranking order for the stressors in patients admitted in ICU.

Stressors

Ranking Order

Observing treatment being administered to other patients (Inter personal factor)

1

Not knowing exactly where you are (extra personal factor)

2

Not knowing what time it is (extra personal factor)

3

Listening to the telephone ringing (extra personal factor)

4

Missing your spouse or partner (Inter personal factor)

5

Don’t know the doctors who cares you (Inter personal factor)

6

Having men and women in same room (Inter personal factor)

7

Not receiving the adequate explanation about the treatment and procedure (Interpersonal factor)

8

Having to use oxygen (extra personal factor)

9

Feeling pain (Intra personal factor)

10

 

 

RESULTS:

The mean score of stressors in top ten ranks include interpersonal factors, extra personal factors and intra personal factors. Interpersonal factors include observing treatment being administered to other patients, Missing your spouse or partner etc. The extra personal factors include not knowing exactly where you are, listening to the telephone ringing etc, and intra personal factor include feeling pain, being thirsty etc.

 

Figure I revealed that the mean scores of dimensions of stressors are nearly equal. Thus it is concluded that all dimensions of stressors are equally contributed towards ICU stress.

 

Figure I: Depicts the comparison of dimensions of stressor in patients admitted in ICU.

 

As shown in table 10(10%) samples had high level stress 36(36%) samples had moderate level stress and 54(54%) samples had high level stress.

 

Table 2: Distribution of samples based on level of stress       N = 100

Level of Stress

F

%

Low Level

Moderate Level

High Level

10

36

54

10

36

54

 


Table 3:   Association between mean score of stress and the clinical characteristics of patients admitted in ICU.

S. No

Clinical Characteristics

N

Mean

SD

Stat Result

Sig

1.

 

 

2.

 

 

3.

 

 

4.

 

 

5.

 

 

6.

 

Diagnosis on Admission:

a.     Surgery

b.     Trauma

Diabetes Mellitus:

a.     Yes

b.     No

Hypertension:

a.     Yes

b.     No

Body Temperature:

a.     Normal

b.     Deviated

Respiration Rate:

a.     Normal

b.     Deviated

Visual Analogue Score:

a.     Low Pain

b.     High Pain

 

14

86

 

18

82

 

46

54

 

50

50

 

11

89

 

29

71

 

75.97

64.73

 

63.47

66.93

 

63.10

69.03

 

63.66

68.95

 

62.71

66.75

 

72.643

63.722

 

0.000

3.28

 

2.249

5.178

 

0.166

5.42

 

1.17

5.82

 

1.051

5.072

 

4.86

1.38

 

t value

12.759

 

t value

2.77

 

t value

7.39

 

t value

6.29

 

t value

2.62

 

t value

14.202

 

P<0.05

Sig

 

P<0.05

Sig

 

P<0.05

Sig

 

P<0.05

Sig

 

P<0.05

Sig

 

P<0.05

Sig

 


The above table concluded that there is a significant association between mean scores of stressors and the clinical characteristics of patients such as diagnosis on admission, diabetes mellitus, hypertension, body temperature, respiration rate, visual analogue score since the t-values are significant at P<0.05 level.

 

DISCUSSION:

In the present study the major stressors identified among ICU patients include intra personal factors (84.73%), inter personal factors (88.27%) and extra personal factors (86.2%). The above findings are consistent with Giannie Bionofiore Maria9 identified the stress generating factors in an ICU. The Environmental Stressors Questionnaire (ESQ) was used. The result revealed that unable to sleep, being in pain, having tubes in nose & mouth, not knowing time & place were the stressors identified.

 

It is also added that majority of the samples 54 had high level of stress 36(36%) samples had moderate level of stress & 10(10%) samples had low level stress.

 

The above findings are configured with the study done by Balasubramani10. The findings revealed that 42% of the samples admitted in ICU had moderate level of anxiety, 32% of samples had severe level of anxiety & 26% of samples had panic level of anxiety.

 

There is a significant association found between mean score of stress and selected clinical characteristics of patients such as diagnosis on admission, diabetes mellitus, hypertension, body temperature, respiration rate, and visual analogue score.

 

These findings are supported by Jens Christian11 the result revealed that there was a association between trauma patients and level of stress.

 

It is inferred that several factors need to be considered when choosing specific strategy to relieve stress. So, combined approaches are most effective in relieving stress. Nursing practice has a significant impact on physical and emotional wellness and which can be addressed effectively only by nursing personal.

 

CONCLUSION:

Evidence of recent studies suggests that ICU experience can be very stressful for the patient. Some physical, psychological alteration experienced by the patients in ICU cause negative physical and psychological health concern. Traditional or routine ICU treatment have its benefits over the physical need of the clients but not the psychological and psychosocial need of the patients. The researchers has concluded that ICU patients face many stressors during the stay which could be managed by the nursing personnel.

IMPLICATIONS:

·       The study reveals the fundamental responsibility of the ICU nurse is to support the patients on various domains such as physical, psychological & social which will help to minimize the distress.

·       Measures can be taken to identify the stressors and reduce their impact.

 

REFERENCES:

1.      Kimberly R Boer, Long term prevalence of PTSD in ICU patients, Crit.Care.2007, 11(1):30.

2.      Andreas Valentine, The importance of risk reduction in critically ill patients. Current opinion in critical care, 2010; 16(5):482-86.

3.      Yoel Donchin. The hostile environment of the intensive care unit, current opinion in critical care, 2010; 8(4):316-20.

4.      Sepideh Olausson. A phenomenological study, being cared in a critical care setting, Intensive and critical care nursing, 2013; 1-2, doi:1010/6j. ICCN.2012.02.002.

5.      Martina M. Cart Wright. The high incidence of post intensive care unit anxiety and depression (online) 2012; Available from http://www.psychology/today.com

6.      Skalski CA. Stressors in five client population. Newman System Model based review. J Adv Nurs. (56):69-78.

7.      Mellisa Conrad Stoppler. What is the role of hypothalamus Pituitary – adrenal – axis (HAP) grouping in stress? (online), 2013; 1-4. Available from http://www.medicinenet.com/stress [Accessedon2014Nov11].

8.      Margaret Swarbrick, Wellness: A practice for our lives and work. Journal of Psychosocial Nursing, 2010; 48(7):1-4.

9.      Giannie Bianofiore, Maria. Stress inducing factors in ICUs. Liver Transpl.2005; (8):967-72.

10.   Balasubramaniyan. Assess the level of anxiety in intensive care unit patients. AJNER.2013; 3(2):89-91.

11.   Jense Christian. Incidence of post tramatic stress disorder in prolong surgical Intensive care unit Academy of psychosomatic medicines 2006; 47(3):223-30.

 

 

 

 

 

Received on 30.11.2018         Modified on 29.12.2018

Accepted on 25.01.2019      ©A&V Publications All right reserved

Asian J. Nursing Education and Research. 2019; 9(2):203-206.

DOI: 10.5958/2349-2996.2019.00043.0